Warm neutral living room with linen seating and oak furnishings beside a picture window overlooking a quiet Northern Michigan bay in late autumn.

What Leelanau County's 2026 Sale Prices Say About the Homes That Sold

From January through October 2026, the average Leelanau County home sold for $923,537. That is about 7% more than the $862,220 average for the same ten months of 2025. Over the same stretch, the county's median sale price fell from $670,000 to $649,000. Both figures come from the same sales, as reported by Aspire North REALTORS, the regional REALTOR association.

A buyer comparing Leland with Suttons Bay or Glen Arbor will see one of these numbers quoted as proof that prices are climbing and the other as proof that they are softening. In a county with about 30 closings a month, both numbers depend heavily on which homes happen to change hands. Set against the long run of county records, the 2026 median looks like a small step back from an unusually strong 2025, and over two years the median and the average have risen at nearly the same pace. The township assessment data shows that the gains were not spread evenly.

One set of sales, two directions

The average and the median measure different things. The median marks the middle of the line, with half of all sales closing above it and half below. The average adds up every sale and divides by the count, so one estate on Lake Michigan frontage pulls it up in a way that a dozen modest cottages cannot pull it back down.

In 2026 there were 324 sales through October, compared with 329 over the same months a year earlier. Total dollar volume still rose, from $283.7 million to $299.2 million. Five fewer homes brought in roughly $15.5 million more. With the middle sale $21,000 lower than a year ago, the most likely source of those extra dollars is sales priced well above the middle. Aspire North's county figures don't break the sales out by price, so this is a reading of the arithmetic rather than a count of individual sales. Either way, the middle of the range stayed close to its 2025 level.

Aspire North recommends reading the two figures together in its October 2026 market update. After reporting the Leelanau figures, the association wrote that the split between the two measures illustrates "why looking at both average and median prices provides a more complete picture of the market." The same update reports 34 sales of $1 million or more across the five-county region of Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Antrim and Kalkaska in October 2026, up from 30 in October 2025. That count covers the whole region for a single month, not Leelanau alone.

The same ten months, year after year

Aspire North publishes Leelanau's January-through-October figures for every year back to 2002, always measured over the same window. Laid side by side, the recent years show a pattern that a single year-over-year comparison hides.

Jan–Oct period Sales Average price Median price Average minus median
2019 391 $449,823 $345,000 $104,823
2020 435 $493,449 $375,000 $118,449
2021 454 $576,285 $420,000 $156,285
2022 323 $756,153 $520,000 $236,153
2023 322 $740,600 $556,500 $184,100
2024 317 $805,155 $575,000 $230,155
2025 329 $862,220 $670,000 $192,220
2026 324 $923,537 $649,000 $274,537

Three things stand out.

First, the number of sales has settled. Since 2022, Leelanau has closed between 317 and 329 homes in the first ten months of every year. In 2021 it closed 454. The peninsula is now a market of roughly a third fewer transactions at much higher prices. The 2026 median of $649,000 is about 55% above 2021's $420,000.

Second, the gap between average and median rises and falls. It was $236,153 in 2022, narrowed in 2023, widened in 2024, narrowed again in 2025, and in 2026 reached $274,537, the widest in this run. A gap that moves up and down from one year to the next is what you would expect if the mix of homes sold changes each year, and less like a steady drift in what a typical house is worth.

Third, 2025 explains much of 2026. In that year the median jumped from $575,000 to $670,000, about 16.5%, while the average rose about 7%. The middle of the market had an unusually strong year. Measured from 2024 to 2026, the median rose about 13% and the average about 15%, which is close to the same pace. The 2026 dip of $21,000 in the median is small next to the $95,000 it gained in 2025.

One October is too few sales to read

Monthly figures make the swings larger. In October 2026 alone, Leelanau recorded 37 sales at a $565,000 median, with homes averaging 83 days on market. In October 2025 there were 48 sales at a $792,000 median and 88 days on market. A $227,000 drop in the median from one October to the next would be striking in a county with thousands of sales. With 37, it comes down to which homes happened to close that month.

Earlier Octobers in the same Aspire North report show how much one month can vary. The October median was $600,000 in 2024, $520,000 in 2023 and $525,750 in 2022. Average days on market were 89 in October 2024 but only 54 in October 2023 and 51 in October 2022.

That longer selling time is the October figure most useful to a buyer. Across the five counties in October 2026, Leelanau's 83-day average was second only to Kalkaska's 87. Grand Traverse came in at 74 and Benzie at 67. More time between listing and closing gives a buyer time to compare homes, and in late autumn it means some listings have been on the market since summer.

Where assessed values moved fastest

Sale prices are measured countywide, but Leelanau's 2026 Equalization Report breaks values down by township. It lists the change in county equalized value, a measure of assessed value covering every class of property, from 2025 to 2026 for each local unit. Because it is built from assessments, it is not a sale-price index. It does show where value grew fastest.

Local unit Change in county equalized value, 2025 to 2026
Cleveland Township 23.77%
Leelanau Township 13.02%
Centerville Township 11.72%
Bingham Township 10.35%
Kasson Township 9.88%
Elmwood Township 8.69%
Leland Township 8.60%
Glen Arbor Township 8.11%
Empire Township 8.11%
Suttons Bay Township 6.69%
Solon Township 6.43%
Village of Northport 0.75%
County total 9.68%

The countywide figure in the 2026 Equalization Report was 9.68%. The widest gap sits at the tip of the peninsula. Leelanau Township as a whole rose 13.02%, while the Village of Northport inside it rose only 0.75%. Some of the steepest gains were in townships that are not the peninsula's best-known names. Cleveland Township led by a wide margin, and Centerville and Kasson, home to Maple City's four corners, both outpaced Leland and Glen Arbor. The townships with the largest property bases moved at more modest rates. Glen Arbor Township's equalized value is about $1.32 billion and Leland Township's about $1.39 billion.

For a buyer, the table adds detail the county median cannot. Value is not moving evenly across Leelanau, and the places with the most growth in 2026 assessments were not always the places that set the headline prices. The effect of these values on a tax bill is a separate question. Our Leelanau County property tax guide for buyers covers it, and your own figures are worth confirming with a tax professional.

Pricing one house when the county sells about 30 a month

With 324 sales in ten months, Leelanau averages a little over 30 closings a month across twelve local units. It also mixes waterfront estates in Leland and Glen Arbor, village homes in Suttons Bay and Northport, and acreage around Maple City and Cedar. Any one month's sample in a given category is small. A home's value comes from the few sales most like it: the same shoreline, or the same township and lot size, closed recently enough to reflect today's buyers. The county median says little about any of those.

The 2026 figures still give a comparing buyer some guidance. Through October, more total dollars changed hands than a year ago, on slightly fewer sales. The median held near its 2025 level after a large 2025 gain. Homes took close to three months to sell in October. And assessed values grew fastest in Cleveland, Leelanau, Centerville and Bingham townships. A buyer weighing two parts of the peninsula will learn more from that combination than from a single median quoted on its own.

The November and full-year 2026 numbers will come out over the winter, and their small monthly counts will shift the figures again. The two-year view in the table above will tell you more than any single month.

If you are trying to work out what a specific Leelanau home is worth, as a buyer comparing two townships or as an owner wondering how this year's sales apply to yours, the comparable sales matter more than the county average. Schaub Team Premier Realty is a multigenerational Leelanau family team that reads those sales across the peninsula, and our free property valuation starts with the homes most like yours.

Work With a Team That Knows the Market

Whether you're buying your first property, selling a property, or searching for land or investment opportunities, we combine decades of experience with personalized service to help you make confident decisions.

Follow Me on Instagram